blackcat2000's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Shark Dossier]

Yeah... Some actual animation would be nice

Either that, or actually finish your series, then follow it up with this. As is, it's basically a resubmission of your first animation. Why do that when you can promote your WHOLE series? =)
But seriously, as some people have mentioned, the mystery buttons should say coming soon, or you should mention that it's not yet complete somewhere (if you don't like the advice about submitting a complete version of this after your series). Not to mention, you could name your series and link them to each other within each animation without the need of a "dossier" (i.e. on part 2 you say "Watch part 1, Snowblind UC" or something like that).
Not to mention that no one will be likely to refer to this submission... It has a low score already, and you might as well link the animations together as i suggested above.
I see what you're trying to do, but I think there are probably better ways... Good luck with your series =)

Celx-Requin responds:

I see your point,
now that I think about it, your idea would have made more sense... Fuck

Anyway thanks for the review,
- Celx

[Notepad Drawing Collab 09]

S'good, despite the lack of animation

Obviously as a drawing collab, there won't be much animation, but I'm saying it was good even as such =)
Firstly a few bugs. When you press the 'previous' button, the pictures still more in the same direction (they always seem to move right to left).
Furthermore (and less obvious) I think one of the authors comments may have been left out or replaced (or put there as a deceiving joke >.>) as the Naruto comment popped up twice.
Also, was the collab reference meant to have an authors comment above it when you finish looking at all the pictures?

Anyways, the music was great- calm, background-ish, not too intrusive, overall a good choice. The art was... virtually all great, no disputes. Everything worked smoothly for me (picture scrolling, viewing authors comments, receiving medals when I should) so I can't say anything but good job! =)

JKAmovies responds:

Yeah, there are a few bugs (but nothing too bad though). The pictures were just something that I didn't want, but couldn't fix. And no, the bios shouldn't be with the collab reference (another bug).

But I'm glad you liked it, and hope you look forward to next years :)

[The Catcher]

I'll just say "could be better"

The gameplay was quite boring and repetitive. The storyline was... meh... I didn't quite finish the game (yes I read your "please finish the game" comment) and maybe it's all explained, but the way it is just doesn't quite appeal to me.
The game on hard isn't even hard, by my standards (I'm no pro gamer, either) and in my opinion, there was no reason to have the starting difficulty buttons in both chinese and english (or at least I think it was chinese). The only thing that served for me was making me scared the game would be in chinese too.
I liked the music, it was decent, the artwork decent as well. In fact, they complimented your piece.
Improvements... I think there's not much you can do to actually improve this without totally changing the idea... What comes to mind are shops and upgrades, but I always say that.
Sorry about not being able to find much you can really improve, but I'd still like you to know it was a decent game. Looking forward to any future work, eh.

Todd-Studios responds:

I'd like you to atleast see the bossfight, to maybe change your mind.

You don't have to, but the password, I believe is "bossfight" for intermediate.

[More Bloons]

Sorry, I liked the first one better

Simple. This game is becoming like most other games, with a straightforward goal. Of course, All the graphics and power-ups were awesome, like the first one. However, the first one has something that I found to enjoy much more. That thing is creativity. This version was fun, but in most levels required a single, no mistakes, path, that leads to frustration, whereas in the first one, you could go back to a level and try out many, many ways of passing a level. As I said many times before, it was fun, but it's becoming restricted. Great game though!

Warnockworld responds:

Thanks for the feedback, its always appreciated. More bloons was designed to take the level design as far as I could take it, without repeating too much of what was in the first one. And that usually meant trying to make the levels hard.

Cheers

[Pimp My Gamecube]

Wow... I liked it

I mean, it's a dress-up game, but, it's new! *dresses up game cube I don't have in bikini*. Seriously, this was good, the music wasn't TOO shabby, I found this amusing too... Don't know about others, but I'm giving this a good rating. The graphics were only OK, but still good, since everything matched up quite well, as in, not like those other dress-up games where the shirts are too big etc. Good job, keep it up, maybe something even newer and different! ;)

KentWolf responds:

lol Thanks for the score. And yes I'm working on something new lol

[Kingdom Fire Demo]

I HATE this game

But only because I can't continue after level 1 >:(... I can't wait for the full version to come out, you know, by doing this you're forcing me to find some other random game to play until June? I fink yoo ar ebil, pure ebil. Anyway, It's fantastic (but it's annoying because i tried to everything perfectly, to find I can't continue) but now I'm on the edge of my seat, waiting, waiting...

Nemo responds:

Sorry to keep you in anticipation, but I guess that will make it all the better when it finally shows up! I'm really glad you liked it. Thanks for the great (humorous) review!